GoDaddy called me today and said that they screwed up and allowed us to add an already existing domain (on some other clients certificate) to our certificate and that I needed to remove it. Ok. Done.
Godaddy: thanks, you have 24 hours to install your the newly generated certificate.
Thanks Godaddy, it’s Friday evening and my IT guys are out for the next 2 weeks. (It’s actually not that hard to do, but come on…)
You can just follow the online instructions to get the certificate up and running on IIS 7: http://help.godaddy.com/article/4801#Install_IIS7 So that got three of my sites back on using SSL.
Now when I went to update our IIS 6 websites, it wouldn’t work… So I called GoDaddy, maybe they’d give me some support.
Godaddy: Sorry sir, we don’t support how to export the SSL certificate from IIS 7 to IIS 6.
Me: Oh, that’s all I have to do? *hang up*
So I just went back into IIS 7, exported my certificate to a .pfx, then just imported it to IIS 6. Bam, all my IIS 6 websites were using SSL again 🙂